Inspector Rebus exclusive
The stories are overall very readable, though there is the element of one
dimensional casting of the main man. Boss out to get him, throws a wobbly,
does a double bluffing deal with the bad guys, case solved ! I would buy
more of the same even if there is a degree of accuracy in your opinion.
The TV show bombed in my opinion. I dont think John Hannah was the right
actor to play the part which didnt help. Did Rankin have much input to the
script ?
Laidlaw is a very good read but his character has had a very short shelf
life. I have Laidlaw, The Papers of Tony Veitch and Strange Loyalties.
Reading the Strange Loyalties I was feeling the same about Laidlaw as you
think of Rebus. Not his best attempt at a crime story given the first two
efforts, which I have read many times. Maybe that is why we have only seen
three crime stories from McIlvanney. The third was was not exactly a crime
story but a follow-up meandering tale of a cop struggling with life after
his brothers death. On a like for like basis it is harder to judge the
potential success of Laidlaw.
Kevin.
|