"With his bold opinions, quick wit and colorful use of language, Roth showed ample potential"
Good or bad, he's no Howard Stern
AK NAHAS
Give him credit for not being a Howard Stern clone.
Landing on terrestrial radio last Tuesday, David Lee Roth sounded more
like a mix of Dr. Phil, Dr. Laura and Pittsburgh's own Jim Quinn.
The Roth show, heard locally on WRKZ-FM (93.7), debuted dismally, but
by Friday the former Van Halen singer hit a groove that made his show
fairly entertaining, or at least worth a few more listens.
Focusing on listener phone calls and his own rapid-fire riffing, Roth
wisely has left the strippers, drunken dwarves and crazy cabbies to
his predecessor, Stern, whose Sirius Satellite Radio show premieres
Monday.
The bigger risk by the 51-year-old Roth is his refusal to load his
show with celebrity guests. Roth explained he doesn't want to
interview Hollywood stars because then he'd have to pretend he saw
their latest movie.
That's a refreshing attitude, but it backfired during Roth's most
crucial hour - the 8 to 9 a.m. drive time slot on his debut show -
when he spent the entire time interviewing his Uncle Manny, a World
War II veteran and 1950s Greenwich Village club owner.
With his stories about bombing Berlin and booking Peter, Paul & Mary,
Manny was the perfect radio guest ... for an AM nostalgia station like
WJAS (1320.)
Things hadn't improved much by Wednesday for listeners who tuned in to
hear an emergency medical technician discussing the importance of 911.
Just what gridlock-weary commuters need - a boring lecture. Roth has
undergone extensive training as a New York City EMT, something he
talked about at great length last week.
The Roth show improved Thursday and Friday when the host fielded phone
calls and dispensed advice on relationships and parenting. Though his
show is heard throughout eastern and Midwestern markets, most of those
callers had Brooklyn accents that "Saturday Night Fever's" Tony Manero
would have struggled to comprehend.
At times, his conversations with listeners turned political, allowing
Roth to get on a soapbox on issues such as gun control (he's opposed,
though he says hunters should only be allowed in the woods after
receiving extensive gun training).
With his bold opinions, quick wit and colorful use of language, Roth
showed ample potential. He fired off some funny one-liners ("The
problem with Cuban coffee," he said, "is that a week later I'm drowsy
again.") and displayed a proper mix of defiance and humor in dealing
with the inevitable crank-calling Stern fans.
But with no provocative guests to grill, Roth's shtick sometimes grew
tiresome. To maintain a verbal flow, Roth surrounded himself in the
studio with several underlings, none of whom contributed much in the
way of humor or insight, though in fairness we should give them time
to see if there's a Stern-styled Stuttering John or Baba Booey in the
bunch.
Roth, too, deserves a few more weeks to fine-tune his show.
Though, if he doesn't soon find someone more interesting than Uncle
Manny to talk to, WRKZ officials might want to start figuring out a
backup plan.
|