Mombu the Religion Forum sponsored links

Go Back   Mombu the Religion Forum > Religion > Hilberg on Auschwitz (way don)
User Name
Password
REGISTER NOW! Mark Forums Read

sponsored links


Reply
 
1 29th August 07:00
seni revlow
External User
 
Posts: 1
Default Hilberg on Auschwitz (way don)


Yours is the '85 edition. I said current editions, which you chose to
ignore. Things have been revised over the last few years - that's
what revisionists do. Hilberg relegated gas chambers to a footnote.

We're talking gas chambers here and only gas chambers. I don't have
to prove anything. OTOH, you check a current edition and find gas
chambers anywhere, other than a single footnote, then come back and
either admit I'm right or rub my nose in it.


Like I said, prove me wrong.

Then don't just blather, refute my point.


Show me I'm wrong.

What quotes? Tsk, tsk.

Revisionists are big enough to admit when in error. You, OTOH, are never wrong, right?

Anyone who is following this thread can see right through you.


Daffer knows he's in trouble and decides to shout:

You don't believe what I say and love to call me a liar.
So, tough guy, get a current edition and look up gas chambers.

Here's the tap dance line:

You do know I'm right, don't you?

Relegating gas chambers to a footnote implies that *HE* is stepping
back. I never implied anything. I just made a statement of fact.

That's all you have is smear. No where to turn except insults.

Just think how happy you'll be if you can find gas chambers mentioned
in anything but a footnote. Now get crackin', boy.

sr
--
"The only way we can learn from the Holocaust is by restoring it as a
rational object of historical inquiry, and the only way we can do that
is by putting the Holocaust industry out of business."
Norman G. Finkelstein
  Reply With Quote


  sponsored links


2 29th August 07:00
seni revlow
External User
 
Posts: 1
Default Hilberg on Auschwitz (way don)


I'll be poking you in the eye with truth, but you're used to it.

You don't realize what happened here, do you? Gotcha!


sr
--
"We should get rid of the ones who are not Israeli citizens the same
way you get rid of lice. We have to stop this cancer from spreading
within us.''
Israeli minister, Rehavam Zeevi
  Reply With Quote
3 8th September 19:29
william daffer
External User
 
Posts: 1
Default Hilberg on Auschwitz (bit way don)


Seni Revlow <senirevlow@earthlink.net> writes:

Several posts ago you claimed that you 'notice everyhing.' You
implied that you'd read the entirety of the latest edition of _The
Destruction of the European Jews_.

Are you now claiming that it wouldn't be a justifiable
conclusion upon reading those 1200 pages that Hilberg had ceased to
believe in the existence and operation of the gas chambers?

Are you beginning to feel stupid? You should.


Not that either you or Morghus can prove. You both can shout your
claims to the rooftops, but that's quite a bit different from
proving them, now isn't it? Even you understand that, don't you?

I don't have the latest edition of Hilberg, but I *strongly* suspect
that both you and Morghus don't either, that you're just repeating
some lie from some denier website you've read and that you really
don't know one way or the other!

Try to prove me wrong. Let's see if you have any ****ing guts, for
once. whd --
In Message-ID: <v4bi84intrdi8e@corp.supernews.com>
"Tommy15-Wcw" <Tommy@noMail.com>


Yeah.
  Reply With Quote
4 8th September 19:30
seni revlow
External User
 
Posts: 1
Default Hilberg on Auschwitz (mind time way don)


What I said was: " I made note of just about everything. That's my forte."


I implied nothing of the sort - That's what you inferred.
The fact is, however, I did read every page. That's why I conclude
that Hilberg is a revisionist and an honest man.


I don't know what is in Hilbergs mind, I can only read his writin.'


Not in the least. You continue to look pretty dumb tho.


We're not shouting, you are. You need to compare your old book with
the new book. At that point you can come back and say either "You
guys are full of shit - gas chambers are mentioned on pages . . . "
Or
"Gee you guys are right - gas chambers are NOT mentioned except in a
footnote."
This is your chance to win one - go for it.


Well, go get it.

You're just digging yourself deeper -keep it up.


Proving you wrong is easy, as I have demonstrated time and again.
This is your opportunity, go for it.

Until that time, this conversation is on hold. Please don't don't
waste my time.

sr
--
"The only way we can learn from the Holocaust is by restoring it as a
rational object of historical inquiry, and the only way we can do that
is by putting the Holocaust industry out of business."
Norman G. Finkelstein
  Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes




Copyright 2006 SmartyDevil.com - Dies Mies Jeschet Boenedoesef Douvema Enitemaus -
666