Edwin clark 2010-04-08 17:34:53
Perhaps it is premature for you to send this letter since you
yourself have not yet seen the papers? Also, I recommend that you give more
precise references. If you read the manuscript
by Bruce Berndt, et al, you will see that there is some question about
the possible existence of a joint paper by Cockle and Harley. How do
you expect the poor editor to know what papers you are talking about.
And what will you say if the referee says, “Yes, I read them, but have
You are leaving yourself open to possible embarrassment, don’t you think?
Or, maybe by now you have read the papers and I missed your posting on the
content and comparison to your work?